A Misfire That Killed the Computer: Replace the Coil Before the New One Goes In

One of the most avoidable ways to lose an engine computer is to install it on a vehicle that still carries the part that killed the last one. It happens often enough that we bring it up on the phone, in email and now here, because the replacement can be destroyed within seconds of the first start.

This is the failure mode where the computer genuinely is bad and the computer was never the real problem.

How a coil or injector damages a computer

On the great majority of port injected and coil on plug engines, the computer does not merely tell something else to fire the coils and injectors. It switches them directly, using transistor driver circuits inside the module. Each driver completes the ground path for one coil or one injector, thousands of times a minute, for the life of the vehicle.

Those drivers are sized for a healthy component. An ignition coil or a fuel injector has a winding with a specific resistance, and that resistance is what limits how much current flows through the driver.

When a coil or injector fails with an internal short, that resistance collapses. The winding that should have limited current to a safe level now lets far more through, and the driver inside the computer is asked to carry current it was never designed to handle. Sometimes it survives for a while. Often it burns out, and once a driver is gone, that cylinder is dead no matter what you plug into it.

The same logic applies to anything else the computer switches directly: transmission shift solenoids, EGR valves, purge and vent solenoids, idle air control motors, variable valve timing solenoids and cooling fan circuits.

What it looks like

  • A dead misfire on one cylinder, or on one pair of cylinders if the engine uses a waste spark system where one coil fires two
  • A new coil or injector on that cylinder that does not fix it
  • A misfire code that stays on exactly the same cylinder no matter what is swapped
  • No switching signal on that circuit when tested at the connector with the engine cranking, while the neighbouring cylinders show a normal signal
  • Occasionally a blown fuse that keeps blowing
  • Sometimes a burning smell, or visible scorching on the old coil

The test that settles it: with the wiring between the computer and the component proven good, check whether the computer is actually commanding that circuit. If the signal is there and the component is new and good, look elsewhere. If the signal is absent on one cylinder and present on the others, the driver inside the computer is damaged.

Which vehicles this happens on

It can happen on anything where the computer drives coils or injectors directly, which is most modern vehicles. Some patterns are better known than others:

  • General Motors has published a diagnostic procedure for exactly this, covering 2012 to 2014 Chevrolet Impala, Equinox and Camaro, Buick LaCrosse, Cadillac XTS, SRX and ATS, and GMC Terrain. It walks a technician through a misfire on one cylinder and ends by saying that if the spark plug is dry and enriching the intake makes the misfire less severe, you should suspect a weak or inoperative injector driver in the engine control module. Note what it has the technician do first: swap the coil and plug to another cylinder.
  • Ford 7.3 and 6.0 litre diesels put the injector drivers in their own separate module rather than in the computer, and that module is a known failure item in its own right. Heavy duty General Motors diesels use a dedicated driver module too, with its own family of injector driver circuit codes.
  • Ford, Lincoln and Mercury coil on plug engines, and Chevrolet, GMC, Buick and Cadillac coil near plug engines, use the arrangement described above, where the computer switches the coil directly.
  • Chrysler, Dodge, Jeep, Ram, BMW, Mercedes-Benz, Toyota, Honda, Nissan, Hyundai and Kia all use the same basic arrangement and are all capable of the same failure.

Being straight with you about the evidence: the mechanism is well established and General Motors documents the diagnosis on named vehicles. What is harder to find is a manufacturer stating in writing that a specific shorted coil destroyed a specific driver. So treat the brand list above as "this is how these systems are built," not as a league table of which vehicles do it most.

The step people skip

Here is the whole point of this article. The shorted coil or injector is still on the engine. If it goes back in with the new computer, it will do the same thing to the new driver, sometimes before you have left the driveway.

Before you install a replacement:

  • Replace the coil or injector on the affected cylinder, even if it "tests okay" with a basic resistance check. A winding can short only when hot or only under load, and a cold resistance reading will not show it.
  • Measure the resistance of every coil and injector on the engine, not just the suspect one, and compare them against each other. One that reads noticeably lower than its neighbours is the problem child.
  • Inspect the wiring between that component and the computer for chafing, melted insulation and corroded terminals. A wire shorted to ground does exactly what a shorted coil does.
  • Check the spark plugs. A worn plug with an excessive gap makes the coil work much harder and dramatically shortens its life. Fitting a new coil to a worn plug starts the clock again.
  • Check plug boots and wires for tracking and carbon paths.
  • Look at the whole set. Coils tend to be the same age and to have lived the same life. When one fails shorted on a high mileage engine, the others are candidates.

While you are at it: the damage the misfire itself has been doing

A dead cylinder is not a harmless inconvenience, and this is worth understanding before you drive the vehicle any further.

First, an honest qualifier that most articles on this subject leave out. Many modern vehicles cut fuel to a cylinder once they detect it misfiring badly, specifically to protect the catalytic converter. On those vehicles the raw fuel story below does not apply, or applies only for the period before the computer worked it out. On vehicles without that strategy, and on any engine where the misfire is intermittent enough to keep fuelling it, it very much does.

The converter

A converter normally runs somewhere around 500 to 800 degrees Fahrenheit, and up to roughly 1200 under heavy load. Fuel that leaves the combustion chamber unburned travels down the exhaust and burns inside the converter instead, which is not where combustion is supposed to happen. Temperatures climb far past the normal range, and the ceramic substrate can soften, melt and partially block the exhaust.

That is why a flashing check engine light means stop driving. The flash is not a general warning. It is a specific, reserved signal, required to blink once per second, that means misfire at a level the manufacturer has determined will damage the converter.

One caution in the other direction: a steady light does not prove the misfire is harmless. On vehicles that cut fuel to the dead cylinder, the light is permitted to stay on steadily rather than flash, precisely because the fuel shutoff is already protecting the converter. A steady light with a hard misfire still needs attention.

Worth knowing if a converter has already been replaced: a converter destroyed by a misfire will be destroyed again by the same misfire. The root cause has to be fixed first or you buy two.

The engine itself

Where fuel is still being delivered into a cylinder that never fires, it goes somewhere, and some of it ends up on the cylinder wall. Gasoline is a solvent, and it thins and displaces the thin oil film the piston rings rely on. Less oil film means more metal to metal contact between the ring face and the bore, which accelerates wear on both and in a bad case scores the cylinder wall.

Fuel that gets past the rings ends up diluting the oil in the sump. Thinner oil produces a thinner film in every bearing in the engine, so the consequence is not limited to the cylinder that is misfiring. This is a well understood mechanism, though how much damage a given misfire does over a given number of miles is not something anyone can put a reliable number on.

The spark plug, and why the misfire can outlive the repair

A plug sitting in a wet, unfired cylinder gets fouled with fuel and carbon, which creates a conductive path across the insulator that bleeds ignition energy to ground instead of jumping the gap. The practical consequence catches people out: a fouled plug can keep the cylinder dead even after you have fixed the actual fault. If you have replaced the coil and the computer and that cylinder is still down, put a new plug in it before you start looking for a third problem.

So a misfire left for weeks may have cost more than a coil and a computer. Check the oil for a fuel smell and for a level that has risen rather than dropped, and change it once the misfire is fixed.

Getting it right the second time

Fix the cause, then replace the computer, then start it. In that order. Our pre order checklist covers the rest of what to rule out, and our warranty page explains what is covered.

If you are not certain whether a driver circuit is genuinely damaged, email Help@TheECUConnection.com with your VIN, the misfire codes and what you have already replaced. It is a short conversation and it is a lot cheaper than two computers.